What's Actually in the Tin: A November Seed Audit Before the 2027 Catalogues Land
Photo: Wm. Henry Maule (Firm); Henry G. Gilbert Nursery and Seed Trade Catalog Collection, No restrictions, via Wikimedia Commons
The catalogues will start arriving any day now, glossy and confident, with photographs of tomatoes that have never existed in a British summer. And every one of them will make a persuasive case that what your growing year needs is more varieties.
What it probably needs is fewer. Which is why the most useful gardening job of the year happens in November, at the kitchen table, with a cup of tea and the seed tin.
This isn't really a gardening article, or not only. It's about the eating year: the gap between what we sow, what we harvest and what we genuinely cook. A seed audit is where those three things get lined up — or quietly admitted not to match.
Why November, not January
January is for buying. November is for looking honestly at what you've got, while the last of the season is still in your mind and before the catalogues have done their work on you.
By now you know how the year actually went. You remember which beans you never picked, which lettuce bolted in the first warm week, and which one variety quietly earned its space every single fortnight. That knowledge has a shelf life of about six weeks. Use it while it's fresh.
The audit, in four steps
Empty the whole tin out. Not a rummage — an actual emptying, onto a tray or the table, so you can see everything at once. Most seed collections are roughly twice the size their owner thinks they are.
Sort into three piles. Things you actually sowed this year. Things you meant to sow. Things you'd forgotten you owned, which is usually the biggest pile and often contains three nearly identical packets of parsley.
Check every date. Most packets carry a sow-by year. Ignore the month on it and treat the year as approximate — seed kept cool and dry will often beat its date by a couple of seasons, and seed kept in a shed will fail well before it.
Decide, out loud, what you're not growing. This is the step that changes things. Not 'maybe next year' — an actual decision, recorded somewhere. Two chilli varieties, not six. One courgette, because one courgette feeds a street.
What keeps, and what really doesn't
Some seed is genuinely durable. Beans, peas, brassicas, beetroot, chard and most of the squash family will still germinate respectably at three, four or five years old if they've been stored somewhere cool and dry. These are the packets worth keeping and the ones it's daft to re-buy.
Others are famously short-lived and simply aren't worth the gamble: parsnip above all, plus onion, leek, carrot and salsify. Old parsnip seed is the classic reason for a bald row in April and a quiet sense of grievance in May. Buy those fresh each year, in small quantities, and accept it.
Tomatoes and peppers sit in the middle — usually fine at two or three years, noticeably weaker beyond that. And if you've saved your own seed from open-pollinated plants, label it properly now. 'Small brown seeds, 2024' is a puzzle, not a packet.
The kitchen-paper test
For anything you're unsure about, don't guess. Count out ten seeds, lay them on a piece of damp kitchen paper, fold it, seal it in a bag or a jar and leave it somewhere warm-ish for a week to ten days.
Then count what's sprouted. Seven or more out of ten, sow as normal. Four to six, sow more thickly than usual and accept a thinner row. Two or three, and it's compost — that's not failure, it's information you'd otherwise have discovered in June with nothing to show for it.
It costs ten seeds and a bit of paper to find out. The alternative costs a whole sowing window.
Storing the survivors properly
Most seed dies of damp and heat, not age. The shed is the worst place for it: bone dry in June, condensation and mouse-adjacent in January. A tin in a cool cupboard, ideally with a little silica sachet from a shoebox, is much better.
Keep the packets sealed, keep them labelled, and write the year on anything you decant into an envelope. Group them by family rather than by year — all the brassicas together, all the salads together — so that next spring you can find what you need in one go instead of buying a replacement because the original couldn't be located.
Order less, sow more reliably
Here's the argument in one line: a small number of varieties, sown in succession, at the right time, will feed you far better than a large number sown once in a rush during a sunny weekend in April.
So when the 2027 catalogues do arrive — and they will — set yourself a limit before you open them. Three new varieties, say. Everything else has to come from the tin, or be a replacement for something you've genuinely run out of. Write it on the envelope. It's harder to break a rule you've written down.
And buy the small packets. Half the cost, half the waste, and roughly the same number of plants in a small garden. The economics only work out in favour of the big packet if you're actually going to sow it.
A small-space plan with room to change your mind
If you're growing on a balcony, in a couple of raised beds or a few pots by a wall, a realistic 2027 might look like this:
- One salad crop, sown every three weeks from March, rather than six varieties sown in one go. Lettuce, rocket, or a cut-and-come-again mix.
- One climbing thing. Beans or peas against a wall or a wigwam; something to pick while standing up.
- Two pots of herbs that you actually cook with. Not eight. Thyme and parsley, or mint if you're realistic about how much mint you use.
- One 'treat' crop — tomatoes, chillies, whatever makes you happy — with the understanding that it may fail and that this is part of the deal.
- Something for the winter, sown in July: kale, chard, or a hardy salad for the windowsill, so that next November you're still eating from the plot rather than only planning it.
That's five decisions, not fifty. And crucially, it leaves room — for the weather, which will do what it wants, and for you to change your mind in May, which you will.
The seed tin should be a working thing, not an archive. Empty it now, be honest about what's in there, and by spring every packet you own will have a reason to exist. That's a better start to a growing year than any catalogue can offer.