Kale & Bee All articles
Honey & Pantry

Line Up the Jars: A No-Equipment Honey Tasting for a Wet Sunday Afternoon

Kale & Bee
Line Up the Jars: A No-Equipment Honey Tasting for a Wet Sunday Afternoon

Photo: Print artist: Utagawa Kuniyoshi (歌川国芳) Published by: Tsutaya Kichizo (蔦屋吉蔵), Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

There is a reasonable chance you already own a honey tasting. It's in the cupboard, behind the tinned tomatoes: two jars from a farm shop, one that arrived in a hamper, and something dark and slightly mysterious at the back that a relative brought back from a weekend away in the summer.

You don't need a pipette, a tasting glass, a course or a special notebook. You need a teaspoon, a bit of paper and twenty minutes where nobody asks you what's for dinner.

The point isn't to become a honey expert. It's to stop buying the same anonymous jar out of habit when there are four quite different things sitting a foot apart in your own kitchen.

Start with what's already open

The temptation is to go out and buy a set of specialist jars before you begin. Resist it. Tasting your own cupboard is more interesting, because it's the honey you'll actually eat this week.

Choose three, or four at a push. Beyond that the palate gets muddled, the notes get vague, and it starts to feel like homework. What you want is contrast rather than a collection:

British honey lands in usefully different places. A pale borage or lime honey tastes of almost nothing until it tastes of everything; a warm amber wildflower is broad and friendly; heather is dark, thixotropic and famously divisive; rapeseed sets within weeks and has a faintly cabbagey edge that some people love and others don't.

Let the jars stand on the counter for an hour before you start. Cold honey gives up very little — the aroma is locked into the crystals and the texture is tight and unhelpful.

Setting up, which takes about five minutes

One small spoon per jar. A glass of water. Something plain and slightly acidic to reset your mouth between tastes — a slice of apple is ideal, or a finger of bread. Skip the coffee, the marmalade and the strong tea until afterwards.

Label each spoon with a scrap of paper, or simply line the jars up in a row and taste left to right without moving anything. You will, otherwise, absolutely confuse the third jar with the fourth and write a note about the wrong honey. Everyone does.

Work from light to dark. It's the same logic as tasting wine or cheese: delicate things first, or the big ones will steamroll them.

A score sheet of four lines

You can make this as elaborate as you like, but four categories out of five is plenty, with a line for notes underneath. Write the name of the jar down before you taste it.

Aroma

Smell the jar, then stir the honey with the spoon and smell again — a lot of the volatile aromatics only show up once you've disturbed it. What's there? Warm hay? Toffee? Citrus peel? A slightly dusty, malty smell? A whiff of something almost savoury? Don't reach for the fancy words. Reach for the first honest one.

Texture

Runny, firm, grainy, coarse, waxy, silky, or stubbornly solid enough to stand a spoon in. Look at the crystals too: fine-grained set honey feels quite different in the mouth from a coarse one that crunches slightly. None of these are faults; they're just notes.

Sweetness

Not 'how sweet is it' — all honey is sweet — but how fast the sugar arrives. Some jars hit immediately and fade quickly. Others come in slower and sit longer, which usually means more going on behind the sugar.

Finish

The bit after you swallow, which is where the interesting things happen. Does it stop dead? Does it leave a warm, slightly bitter edge? A tang? A faintly waxy feeling at the back of the throat? Ivy honey, for instance, has a strong and oddly savoury finish that you'll either find fascinating or file under 'never again'.

Underneath those four, one line: does this taste of anything beyond sweet? If the answer is no, write that down honestly. It's a perfectly good note.

The honest pairings

Pairings in honey writing tend to get grand. Here's the plain version, tested on ordinary Sundays.

Toast. Set honey on hot buttered toast, runny honey on cold. A dark, strong honey on sourdough is a lot first thing in the morning; a pale lime or clover honey is the better everyday jar. If you only ever own one honey, make it a light one.

Cheese. Salty hard cheese — a decent mature Cheddar, a bit of Caerphilly — takes a dark honey well. Blue cheese and heather honey is a genuinely good combination and takes thirty seconds: a spoon of honey in a ramekin next to the wedge, no drizzling faff, no decorative puddle.

Roast roots. Parsnips, carrots, celeriac, chunked and roasted hot, with honey stirred through in the last five minutes rather than at the start, so it glazes instead of burning. A mild amber honey is right here; a medicinal one will fight the vegetables.

Tea. Stir honey into black tea once it's cool enough to drink, not while the water is still boiling — the aromatics flatten and you've wasted a good spoon. And some teas are better with nothing in them at all, which is also allowed.

Rinse the spoons between jars if you're being thorough, or don't if you're tasting in the spirit of curiosity rather than connoisseurship. A trace of the previous honey in the next one is not a crisis.

What to do with the notes

Keep them. Stick the sheet inside the cupboard door or in the back of whatever notebook you use for shopping lists. Next time you're standing in front of a market stall trying to remember whether you liked the dark one or the pale one, you'll have an answer instead of a vague feeling.

The other thing worth writing down is a sentence you can say out loud, because that's the real skill here: I like a light honey for toast and a dark one for cheese, and I don't much care for the medicinal ones. That's a tasting note. It also means you'll stop buying jars that sit at the back of the cupboard for two years.

And if none of the jars in your kitchen turn out to be your favourite — good. That's a useful thing to have discovered on a rainy afternoon for the price of a spoon.

All Articles

Related Articles

After the Roast: A Small Finishing Spoon of Honey for Pan Juices

After the Roast: A Small Finishing Spoon of Honey for Pan Juices

The Jar Isn't Finished: Three Small Kitchen Uses for the Last of the Honey

The Jar Isn't Finished: Three Small Kitchen Uses for the Last of the Honey

Sharp, Sweet, Soon: A Fridge Jar of Red Cabbage for Cold-Weather Plates

Sharp, Sweet, Soon: A Fridge Jar of Red Cabbage for Cold-Weather Plates